WPC E䞶T-WfeAAsDY֥6-[kT찑jQ_PG}AҧI> sK@}7g^HϯZض7)dn@:XSN#f=jC^©gtFyv/z݀>vƞӗGLQ>s6 ;4z_1\{:a)$ď O|Rݺ=T/U ǕQɖ#W8ekg5[t{H,lلiުb\s۵P4xD@FK/cՀuC}dψQK?vanq |JGdlXwHH0eRNbe*$HeMKQJԈNEf =*jk+:AFWg' >qkb;N:MM-!U>  0n 0n& 0b 0n 0 Bd 0A 0 0:l   0 U. B 0C  '# 0:J 0#JUN %aMg(kN^ w4 m\  `&Times New Roman' RITA L &Rita L. Swenor(0Jonathan Soglin .   <:Default ParaXXX< :Footnote Te1XXX0 .Style1XXX< :Footnote TexXXX<:Footnote Ref86Hyperlink60> .Footer !>44 <DL!>:8Page Number    .)..      X7XXXX7XXX7   ! !X!     (2.$ '!..      X7XXXX7XXX7  $Verdana d($      '!..      X7XXXX7XXX7      fhX7  1    ݀TheoriginalsofthesedocumentsareintheCaliforniaStateArchives.Pleasesee  SecretaryofStatecertificationstampatpages9,25,35,39,42.X7Xf  '!..      X7XXXX7XXX7  |XX7        2    ݀f|Allreferencestopagenumbersaretothe Batesstampednumberonthebottom  rightofeachpage.X7Xf(2~$ '!..      X7XXXX7XXX7  7XXX7  0  #|x('$..      X7XXXX7XXX7HP LaserJet 1200 Series PCL 60(9 Z6Times New Roman RegularXL)3 3PagesU '!..      X7XXXX7XXX7  _      XX87XXdd8   fXX7RITAL.SWENOR  AttorneyatLaw  StateBarNo.85665  582MarketSt.Suite605  SanFrancisco,CA94104  (415)2919401   AttorneyforMinorandAppellant,   CHRISTOPHERA. x    INTHECOURTOFAPPEALOFTHESTATEOFCALIFORNIA, c  FIRSTAPPELLATEDISTRICT,DIVISIONTWO U      InReCHRISTOPHERA., <      D )No.A108438 2  4    <      D ) +{ ЀAPersonComingUndertheJuvenile   D ) $t ЀCourtLaw.   <      D ) m ______________________________________) f  4    <      D )ContraCosta _ PEOPLEOFTHESTATEOFCALIFORNIA, D )SuperiorCourtNo. X  4    <      D )J0400898 Q  4   PlaintiffandRespondent, D ) J  4    <      D ) C  Xvs.   <      D ) <    <      D )  5  XCHRISTOPHERA.,  <      D ) !.    4    <      D ) "'  4   DefendantandAppellant. D ) #   ______________________________________ D ) $ !     APPELLANTSREQUESTFORJUDICIALNOTICEPURSUANTTO & "# EVIDENCECODESECTIONS452AND459 '#$      l<`    4 Appellant,ChristopherA.,requeststhisCourttakejudicialnoticeofthe )$&  followingdocumentsattachedtothisapplication,whicharecontainedinthe +&(        legislativehistoryofWelfareandInstitutionsCodesection202( section202)  addedbyStats.1984,ch.756,1,2pp.27262727:  |f{j,|   1     L   G {jf G    4 1.EnrolledBillReport,dated8/14/84,fromtheYouthAuthority,Youth  andAdultCorrectionalAgency(pp.34);     2           4 2.EnrolledBillReport,dated8/15/84,fromtheSocialServicesdepartment x  oftheHealthandWelfareAgency(pp.56); j   4 3.EnrolledBillReport,Dated8/14/84,DepartmentofFinance(pp.79); \   4 4.AssemblyCriminalLaw&PublicSafetyCommittee,minorityanalysis N  ofthebill,4/2/84(p.10); @  4 5.BillAnalysis,YouthandAdultCorrectionalAgency,YouthOffender 2 ParoleBoard(pp.1112); $t  4 6.BillAnalysis,YouthandAdultCorrectionalAgency,YouthAuthority, f dated3/3/84(pp.1314); X  4 7.ReportofAssemblyCriminalLawandPublicSafetyCommittee,hearing J dated4/4/84(pp.1517); <  4 8.BillAnalysis,YouthAuthority,datedApril1984(p.18); !.  4 9.DigestofAssemblyThirdReadingofthebillasamendedApril24,1984 #    (pp.1920); %!"  4 10.ReportoftheSenateCommitteeonJudiciary,billasamendedApril24,   1984(pp.2124);   4 11.ReportoftheAssemblyCriminalLawandPublicSafetyCommittee,  hearingdate,4/4/84(pp.2629);    4 12.ReportoftheSenateCommitteeonJudiciary,onbillasamendedApril x  24,1984(pp.3034); j   4 13.June14,1984,reportoftheSenateRepublicanCaucusonbillas \  amendedon4/24/84andpassedbyAssemblyon4/30/84(pp.3638); N   4 14.June28,1984,reportoftheSenateDemocraticCaucusonbillas @ amendedon4/24/84andpassedbyAssemblyon4/30/84(p.4041). 2   XAkeyissueinthecaseatbariswhetherthelegislature,inenactingsection $t 202,intendedtoallowacourttorelysolelyonthe punishmentinherentin f commitmenttotheCaliforniaYouthAuthority( CYA)fortherehabilitationofa X delinquentminor.Thisbecameanissueinthiscasewhenrespondenttookthe J positioninitsbriefthatpunishmentofaminorthroughacommitmenttoCYAis, < byitself,inherently rehabilitative. !. Relyingonsection202,subdivision(b)andInreMichaelD.(1987)188 #   Cal.App.3d1392,1396X7Xf,fXX7respondentarguedthat, Therehabilitativevalueina %!" CYAcommitmentliesnotonlyintheprogramsoffered,butinthepunishment '#$ inherentinsuchacommitment.(RB11.)Respondentalsoargued, Sufficeitto )$& saythatthecourtactedwellwithinitsdiscretioninagreeingwiththeviewthat +&( onlyaCYAcommitmentwouldadequatelyservebothaspectsoftheJuvenile -(* CourtLaw:theprotectionofsocietyononehand,andtherehabilitationofthe  minorthroughpunishmentandaccountabilityontheother.(RB18.Italicsadded.)    Inreply,appellantarguedthatinenactingsection202, [R]atherthan  recognizingpunishmentasarehabilitativetool,thelegislatureallowed   punishmenttobeafactorconsideredbythecourtinfashioningadispositionorder x  solongasandonlyifthepunishmentwas consistentwiththerehabilitative j  objectivesofthejuvenilejusticesystem.(ARB7.)Appellanthasrequestedoral \  argumentinthismatterandexpectstofurtheraddressthisissueatthattime. N  Appellantrespectfullysubmitsthatresolutionofthisissueinthecaseatbar, @ asframedbythebriefsofrespondentandappellant,requiresthisCourttoascertain 2 thelegislaturesspecificintentwhenitenactedsection202andstatedthatwhena $t delinquentminorisremovedfromhisorherhomeandorderedintoplacement,the f placementmustprovide care,treatment,andguidanceandthatthe guidance X mayincludepunishmentthatisconsistentwiththerehabilitativeobjectivesofthis J chapter. < ЀThisCourtsroleisto ascertaintheLegislaturesintentsoastoeffectuate !. thepurposeofthelaw.(InreJ.W.(2002)29Cal.4th200,209.)(InreJacobJ. #   (2005)130Cal.App.4th429,434.)Todoso,theCourt mustbeginwiththe %!" wordsofthestatuteastheyaregenerallythemostreliableindicatoroflegislative '#$ intent.(Ibid.citingPeoplev.Gardeley(1996)14Cal.4th605,621.) Whethera )$& statuteisambiguousisnotalwaysreadilyascertainable.Astatutemustbe +&( consideredinthecontextoftherelevantstatutoryframework.(Peoplev. -(* Valenzuela(2001)92Cal.App.4th768,775,citingPeoplev.Goodloe(1995)37  Cal.App.4th485,490491.)Todeterminelegislativeintentinthejudicialreview  ofastatute,itispropertotakenoticeofthoseitemswhichare legitimateindicia  ofthatintent.(Peoplev.Patterson(1999)72Cal.App.4th438,443.)And,   therefore, [j]udicialnoticemayproperlybetakenoflegislativehistory.|f{j|(G {jf GInreGe x  M.(1991)226Cal.App.3d1519,1524,fn.2,citingPostv.Prati(1979)90 j  Cal.App.3d626,634.) \  EvidenceCodesection459,subdivision(a)authorizesareviewingcourtto N  takejudicialnoticeofanymatterspecifiedinEvidenceCodesection452.Section @ 452,subdivision(a)permitsacourttotakejudicialnoticeof theresolutionsand 2 privateactsofthe8.Legislatureofthisstate.EvidenceCodesection452, $t subdivision(c)allowsthecourttotakejudicialnoticeof Officialactsofthe f legislative,executive,andjudicialdepartmentsof8anystateoftheUnited X States.EvidenceCodesection452,subdivision(h),allowsforjudicialnoticeof J  Factsandpropositionsthatarenotreasonablysubjecttodisputeandarecapable < ofimmediateandaccuratedeterminationbyresorttosourcesofreasonably !. indisputableaccuracy. #    X 4 Thedocumentsthatarethesubjectofthisjudicialnoticeapplicationareof %!"  substantialconsequencetothedeterminationofakeyissueonappeal(Evid. '#$ Code,459,subd.(c)),andappellantrespectfullysubmits,supporthisargument. )$& Thus,appellantrespectfullyrequeststhiscourttakejudicialnoticeof,and +&( consider,thematerialssubmittedwiththismotion. -(*  XDate:August30,2005     <     /s/RitaL.Swenor     <     RITAL.SWENOR     <     AttorneyforAppellant   X 4  4  4 X7Xf